Potato salads

Inspiration from near and far

September 28, 2011

“There is no such thing as a really bad potato salad,” Laurie Colwin once wrote. “So long as the potatoes are not undercooked, it all tastes pretty good to me.”

With the exception of gloopy, overly sweet deli-case renditions, I’m inclined to agree. So many flavors shine when paired with potatoes — that blank slate of a tuber — resulting in endless variations on potato salad.

Potatoes, like sponges and hungry teenage boys, absorb whatever you feed them. The essential components of a stellar potato salad include a flavorful dressing, fully cooked potatoes, and something crunchy — celery, onion, peppers, fennel, bacon, etc.

In my book, a good potato salad includes a contrast of textures: soft and yielding potatoes tossed with just the right amount of tangy dressing (not too much, not too little) and paired with the bite of a more piquant ingredient.

What kind of potato to use depends on both the recipe and personal preference. I like the way Russets absorb dressing, Yukon Golds break down and get a little mushy, and red potatoes hold their shape. Sweet potatoes pair beautifully with spicy dressings. Purple potatoes, though I fancy the color, always disappoint — too dry and crumbly. Roasted fingerlings make a nice addition to a composed salad.

Not only does potato salad lend itself to the imagination and reinvention, it’s also easy to throw together. And because most potato salads improve with age, it’s a great dish to make ahead for parties, potlucks, and picnics. A scoop of potato salad rounds out the plate, the perfect side to a sandwich, burger, grilled chicken or steak, ribs . . . you get the picture. Toss enough ingredients into your potato salad, and you can call it lunch or dinner.

Here are eight variations — ideas from near and far — for transforming the humble potato into a noteworthy salad.

  1. Think vinaigrette.
    potato and green bean salad
    Potato and Green Bean Salad
    I adore the tangy, vibrant flavor that comes when potatoes are tossed with vinaigrette; Potato and Green Bean Salad sits at the top of my list. French potato salads call for preparing the salad while the potatoes are still warm, to maximize how much dressing gets absorbed. German potato salads, often served warm, combine a sour and sometimes sweet dressing with the smoky crunch of bacon.
  2. Scandinavian.
    Potato Salad with Lemon, Dill, and Smoked Salmon
    Decadent and delicious, sour cream or crème fraîche make an easy and pleasing dressing to mix with potatoes. Toss cooked new or red potatoes with sour cream, red onion, and fresh dill; season to taste with salt and pepper; and chill. For a meal-in-a-bowl variation, try Potato Salad with Lemon, Dill, and Smoked Salmon.
  3. American classic.
    Culinate’s deli-style potato salad
    A longtime distaste for hard-boiled eggs and sweet relish keeps the classic American picnic salad off my plate. That said, a well-made bowl of this creamy yellow salad — for me, that means not too much mayo, a shot of vinegar, finely chopped eggs, and sour rather than sweet pickles — is a thing of beauty. Our house version is just that.
  4. Seasonal.
    greek potato salad
    Country Potato Salad
    Potatoes in the kitchen are a cook’s blank canvas, easy to pair with whatever ingredients are in season. Country Potato Salad riffs on Greek salad, a vibrant mix of ripe tomatoes and fresh basil. Dilute pesto with olive oil and lemon juice for an easy dressing to toss with potatoes, corn kernels, and cherry tomatoes. Pair green beans and a lemony vinaigrette with potatoes for a popular summer salad that tastes good in early fall.
  5. Sweet potato.
    Sweet Potato Salad with Soy-Ginger Dressing and Peanuts
    I love the taste and texture of roasted or grilled sweet potatoes — caramelized on the outside, soft on the inside. Marry sweet potatoes with a spicy dressing and a crunchy counterpart (peanuts, snap or snow peas, chopped onion, etc.) for a delicious variation on potato salad. It’s a good-for-you option, too: Sweet potatoes rank high in Vitamin A and C, potassium, and fiber.
  6. Go east.
    Aloo Achaar
    Indonesian Gado Gado, a vegetable salad tossed with a warm peanut dressing, often includes boiled potatoes. In Japan, potato salad might be served between two slices of bread or as part of a bento box. Aloo Achaar, an East Indian snack, fuses sesame seeds and chiles into an addictive combination.
  7. Composed.
    Salade Niçoise
    As part of a larger plate, potatoes add both a filling element and a counterpoint to other flavors and textures, not to mention a good host for absorbing a delicious dressing. Think Gado Gado, Salade Niçoise, and Bachelor Salad — a recent Culinate favorite.
  8. Improvise.
    Everything starts with potatoes.
    Mix warm potatoes with House Vinaigrette and you’ve got the start of a delicious potato salad. Add texture — chopped celery, onion, and/or peppers — and then season with fresh herbs, salt, and pepper. If you’ve got black olives or capers, toss them in. Feta or goat cheese add a nice creamy, tangy element. Another angle of inspiration: Take a salad you like (think grain, green, or bean) and swap cooked potatoes for the main ingredient. Potatoes instead of quinoa, Romaine (blue cheese and bacon? Yum!), or black beans would all make a fine salad. You can even make a vegan version that combines potatoes with cabbage.

Carrie Floyd, aka Mrs. Potato Head, is Culinate’s recipe editor.

There are 2 comments on this item
Add a comment
1. by joanmenefee on Sep 28, 2011 at 3:43 PM PDT

Sadly, I am a chronic undercooker. It’s a joke in our household: “If Joan says the potatoes are done, wait ten more minutes.”

2. by ruth_117 on Oct 13, 2011 at 7:13 AM PDT

I love my mom’s potato salad! She mixes in dill pickles, not too many eggs (only one or two for a big bowl!), and a dressing made from mayo, sour cream, mustard and more dill!!! Then she mashes it all together so that there are only a few small chunks of potato and the rest are mashed. So good! Best served with farmers sausage and fresh veggies.

Add a comment

Think before you type

Culinate welcomes comments that are on-topic, clean, and courteous. For the benefit of the community we reserve the right to delete comments that contain advertising, personal attacks, profanity, or which are thinly disguised attempts to promote another website.

Please enter your comment

Format: Bare URLs are automatically linked; use this style: [http://www.example.com "place text to be linked here"] for prettier links. You may specify *bold* or _italic_ text. No HTML please.

Please identify yourself

Not a member? Sign up!

Please prove that you’re not a computer

Our Table

Joy of Cooking app

A new tool for the kitchen

The latest in our collection of cooking apps.

Graze: Bites from the Site
First Person

The secret sharer

A father’s legacy

The Culinate Interview

Mollie Katzen

The vegetarian-cooking pioneer


Down South

Barbecue, tamales, cocktails, and more

Local Flavors

A winter romesco sauce

Good on everything

Editor’s Choice