Vibrant vinegar

How to make your own wine-based vinegar

September 20, 2013

Sometimes, when you have the freshest of lettuces, delicately dressed with your hands and speared with a fork, there’s a moment when your mouth and nose tingle deliciously, and you think, “This is the best salad I’ve ever had.”

That zingy sensation doesn’t come from the tender lettuce or the grassy olive oil or the flaky salt and freshly ground pepper or even the zesty mustard you might’ve added to the dressing. No. It comes from the vinegar.

We overlook vinegar far too often. The very act of forgetting, in fact, is probably what led someone way back when — in, say, Babylonian times — to discover vinegar. If you forget about an open jug of wine for long enough, after all, chances are it will turn into vinegar.

Today, nearly every household in the Western world has a bottle of vinegar stashed away somewhere, just like that forgotten jug of wine. And we tend to take it about as seriously.

As a friend of mine once blurted, “I didn’t know there were differences in red-wine vinegar.”

I had been extolling to her the virtues of Luigi’s Pride, a red-wine vinegar produced by Kirigin Cellars in Gilroy, California. Luigi’s Pride is a muddy red color, with a softer, rounder flavor than the normal bottle of Regina I keep on hand.

Bottle your own vinegar.

Your local supermarket probably carries several dozen varieties of vinegar, both wine-based and not (such as the rice-based vinegars essential in Asian cuisine). But you don’t have to confine yourself to the store shelves. You can buy artisanal vinegars at farmers' markets, wineries, and restaurants.

And it’s relatively easy to make wine-based vinegar yourself, with any wine you prefer.

“The wine I use is better than any wine that anyone would make to use commercial vinegar,” says Gail Monaghan, a Manhattan-based cooking expert. “People say my salads are the best, and I think it’s because of the vinegar.”

Monaghan has been making her own vinegar for well over a decade. Her homemade efforts began when she found some vinegar mother left in a bottle of French red-wine vinegar.

“I thought, ‘Oh, what is this? I bet if I put wine with this mother, it will turn into vinegar.’ That’s how I did it the first time,” she recalls. “It was completely haphazard, and if it hadn’t have worked, I’m sure I just would’ve thrown it out and never thought about it again.”

Erin Coopey, a Seattle-based chef who goes by the moniker The Glorified HomeChef, decided to start making her own vinegar after reading one of French chef Jacques Pépin’s cookbooks.

“I had done flavored and infused vinegars, but I was really inspired by a book that Jacques Pepin put out a few years ago that talked about how his family always had a crock of vinegar going because they would have wine,” says Coopey. “And I just thought, ‘Why wouldn’t I be using my leftover wine to do this?’”

According to Coopey, homemade wine vinegar is entirely different from commercial versions. “There is a sweet nose, and you can actually smell the original wine,” she says.

To make your own vinegar, you need some vinegar mother. You can purchase a vinegar mother online or at a local fermentation shop, or you can just buy a bottle of raw vinegar, such as Bragg's raw apple-cider vinegar or Eden's raw red-wine vinegar. Put the mother, or some of the unfiltered raw vinegar, into a big glass jar or crock. Add wine, cover with cheesecloth, store in a dark place, and wait.

Coopey likes to use a fruity wine, such as zinfandel, for her vinegar. “I’ve also made them from pinot noirs, which are definitely a little more delicate, and I think you need a little bit of structure,” she says. “You don’t have to be a purist when making vinegar. Some people will mix red and white together and just call it one vinegar, but you can just have a crock for red and a crock for white.”

Monaghan’s vinegar-making is more casual. She’s cultivated both white and red vinegar mothers, and just slips a piece of the appropriate mother into an open wine bottle. “I add wine as I have it,” she explains. “I always keep a red one going and a white one going, and once the bottle is full, I put cheesecloth over it and forget about it.”

The vinegarization process usually takes a few months. “You can get a red-wine vinegar to ferment and pretty much be where you want it to be within two to three months, depending on how warm it is,” says Coopey.

The easiest way to do it is to date the bottle or jar, and test it after a month. Once the vinegar has achieved the flavor you want, remove the cheesecloth and cap the bottle — or don’t. “I’m learning the vinegar seems to be better if you don’t just put a lid on it as soon as it’s ready,” says Monaghan. “If you let it sit around a whole lot more, it tends to be a bit richer.”

One chef looking to take things a step further is David Santos, of the New York City restaurant Louro. “I’ve literally been making wine since I was four or five years old, so I used that wine knowledge to add in vinegars,” he says. “I started making all these different wines out of products I had or ordered in, and making vinegars after they had been made into wine.”

Although Louro has been open for less than a year, Santos has already turned such unusual raw ingredients as tomatoes and nori into wine and then further fermented them into vinegars. “Currently we have rice-wine vinegar, Shasta tangerine, tomato, Thai chile, pear, Meyer lemon, kelp, apricot, and mead,” he says. “And then I’m starting beet, peach, and jasmine rice.”

He drizzles the resulting vinegars over a variety of dishes served in the restaurant. “The Thai chile one is so hot,” he says. “And it’s so beautifully aromatic. It’s perfect to drizzle that tiny bit over a larb salad or a cold sesame noodle salad.”

That’s the next step up from homemade: thinking beyond salad dressing to sauces, marinades, even cocktails. “I use vinegar not only in gravies and sauces, but also in soups or stews,” says Coopey. “It livens the palate.”

Jackie Varriano is a writer based in Eugene, Oregon. Keep up with her at SeeJackWrite.

Related recipe: Tomato Vinegar; recipe: Halibut with Beans and Smoked Tomato Vinaigrette; recipe: Chive Blossom Vinegar

There are 2 comments on this item
Add a comment
1. by JudithK on Sep 23, 2013 at 6:50 AM PDT

Ciao. Another way to start a vinegar mother is to simply toss a piece of dry pasta in the red wine that you are trying to ferment into vinegar. Old Italian trick that works very well.
Aceterias (vinegar making jars) are very common in Italy. Basically it’s a large jar with a spigot at the bottom. Keep tossing your left over wine into the jar and you have vinegar on an ongoing basis. When I couldn’t find aceterias in the US, I used a large sangria bottle with a spigot. Works just fine.

2. by Karen Mezzetta on Sep 27, 2013 at 12:06 PM PDT

I’ve tried making wine vinegar with Bragg’s Raw Apple Cider Vinegar. It sat around for several months but never became vinegar. Temp in house is within suggested range. What proportions of wine to Bragg’s should be used? Also, I can attest to Luigi’s Pride - a friend gave me a bottle & it’s terrific, but I’d love to make my own... Tks

Add a comment

Think before you type

Culinate welcomes comments that are on-topic, clean, and courteous. For the benefit of the community we reserve the right to delete comments that contain advertising, personal attacks, profanity, or which are thinly disguised attempts to promote another website.

Please enter your comment

Format: Bare URLs are automatically linked; use this style: [ "place text to be linked here"] for prettier links. You may specify *bold* or _italic_ text. No HTML please.

Please identify yourself

Not a member? Sign up!

Please prove that you’re not a computer

Dinner Guest

The gamification of cooking

Earning points

Most of the time with cooking and eating, the rules are clear.

Graze: Bites from the Site
First Person

The secret sharer

A father’s legacy

The Culinate Interview

Mollie Katzen

The vegetarian-cooking pioneer


Down South

Barbecue, tamales, cocktails, and more

Local Flavors

A winter romesco sauce

Good on everything

Editor’s Choice