The born-again omnivore

How one woman shunned — and then ate — meat

October 6, 2011

Following in the footsteps of college freshmen everywhere, I sent my mother into fits by coming home for Christmas a vegetarian. I had read Diet for a New America, John Robbins’ polemic against the manifold evils of a carnivorous lifestyle; the book places the blame for animal cruelty, environmental destruction, and all forms of bodily illness upon the consumption of beef, pork, chicken, and lamb. As only a good Catholic girl could be, I was consumed by guilt over my history of sinful hamburgers. Robbins promised atonement in a tofu patty.

My sacrifice was actually not that painful, as I had never loved meat. No psychoanalyst needed to understand why: my mother, the source of 18 years of dinners, was a terrible cook. Of all the kitchen atrocities she committed, her transgressions against animal flesh were the most offensive. Her vegetables may have been soft and watery and her pasta gluey, but at least these would yield to the bite. Against my mother’s steak, no jaw was victor.

In addition to providing an excuse not to eat leathery liver, vegetarianism offered a perfect, almost acceptable, teenage rebellion. Too inhibited to experiment with alcohol or sex, I attained some much-needed hipster credentials by experimenting with food instead, replacing the chops and meatloaf of my childhood with ethnic exotica like mung beans, miso, and quinoa. Meanwhile, my mother and I sparred over questions of doctrine: Did chicken stock count? Surely not stuffing? I ate squash and potatoes for Thanksgiving dinner and felt boldly defiant, while continuing to defer to maternal authority on all matters outside the kitchen.

One day, she took a bite of steak.

The earthy-crunchy counterculture I embraced offered a hairshirt cuisine, strong on virtue and weak on flavor. Alice Waters had been preaching the gospel of fresh, bright, and sophisticated meat-free food for years, but the message hadn’t made it to East Coast college campuses. Our beans were bought in dimly lit and poorly swept co-ops, then cooked endlessly in Crock-Pots found at yard sales. Our salads were flattened under sunflower seeds, chickpeas, tahini, and bean sprouts. Lacking the imagination to envision meals centered on fresh vegetables, my housemates and I attempted homemade meat substitutes, freezing tofu to give it the texture of a sea sponge and kneading bread dough under water to produce masses of gluten like a drawer of entangled rubber bands.

My consciousness may have been raised, but my palate remained shackled, my new dinners as dismal as the gray roasts at home.

After graduation, I moved to New York City — my first true act of independence. There I discovered the joys of real food. I bought sourdough bread and cheese at Zabar’s, sampled heirloom apples at the Union Square farmers’ market, journeyed to Chinatown for mushrooms and soba noodles, and stood alongside ancient Greek grandmothers in the Astoria produce market, picking over green beans. The fantastic ingredients inspired heroic acts of cooking. Multicourse meals emerged from my closet-sized kitchen. But for years, I still wouldn’t touch meat.

How to Cook Everything Vegetarian ad

Today I look at my beloved freezer — full of pasture-raised heirloom pork chops, grass-fed beef shanks, and ground bison — and I wonder how I was ever so certain of anything as I once was that I would forever abstain from flesh. I understand now that I was afraid of living without rules, without the comfort of each day setting myself a test I knew I could pass. Growing up for some people means learning limits. For me, it meant letting go of them and, for the first time, embracing pleasure over purity.

The metamorphosis transpired slowly. First fish — always my last-resort choice in restaurants that lacked vegetarian options — became a more frequent indulgence. I gradually stopped interrogating beleaguered waiters about chicken broth hidden in cream of broccoli soup or lard lurking in pie crust. At cooking school, where I enrolled in a pastry program to avoid the culinary track’s lessons in leg of lamb and foie gras, I even nibbled a few tastes of duck à l’orange — to be polite, of course. I still identified as a vegetarian, but my resolve had weakened.

In the end, a steak was my downfall. I was suffering through first big problems of adulthood — a failing marriage, looming unemployment, unpaid bills, and wavering faith — and learning to compromise on issues more looming than the contents of my dinner plate. In search of the special comfort of food cooked by another’s hands, I went to a restaurant one evening nursing a hunger too deep for any salad to satisfy.

I found myself ordering a T-bone, cooked rare. It came to the table sizzling hot, well peppered, salty, and very, very bloody. Each tender, succulent bite was a revelation, offering that familiar beefy flavor, but better than I had ever imagined it could be. The meat juices swam on the plate and dyed the baked potato red. I mopped up every drop.

That dinner marked the true end of my vegetarianism. I could no longer pretend to be indifferent to the call of flesh — not with the memory of that steak enough to make my mouth water. And so I set out to conquer this new world.

Never having learned how to cook as an omnivore, I started with the most boring but unintimidating of cuts: boneless, skinless chicken breasts. But the bland neutrality of those pale slabs satisfied neither my taste buds nor my spirit. If I was going to develop a relationship with meat and find a way to bring my desire in line with my convictions, I had to go much further.

Talking to farmers’ market purveyors with their coolers of beef, pork, and lamb, I discovered a whole network of people committed to the practice of ethical livestock husbandry. Now these were meats that could inspire. Soon endless culinary possibilities opened themselves to me: boeuf à la mode, hunter’s stew, jambalaya, flavorful and complex dishes with history and soul. I learned how to coax tenderness from tough cuts with gentle cooking, how to create gelatinous stock from bones and trimmings, how to make rich dark gravy. In a few thrilling years at the stove, I managed to condense a lifetime of missed lessons in the cooking of animals.

Buying direct from farmers encouraged me to try oft-ignored cuts, leading to such once-unthinkable meals as braised trotters and pickled tongue, cuisine far removed from both the baked chicken of my childhood and the five-bean chili of my early adulthood. I learned to love fare both my mother and John Robbins would find distasteful, to say the least. But my kitchen is my own — not my mother’s, not Robbins’ — and meat, in all its variety, finally has its place at my table.

Kathleen Weldon has worked as a pastry chef, mutual-fund trader, and pollster. She keeps a blog called The Seasonal Cook.

There are 8 comments on this item
Add a comment
1. by anonymous on Oct 6, 2011 at 7:14 PM PDT

Everyone has the right to eat whatever she or he wants. However, I will never agree that there exists an ethical or humane way of killing an animal. Causing death is causing death - there is no other way of looking at it.

2. by Ben @ NutritionHub on Oct 7, 2011 at 8:44 AM PDT

Very interesting article. I grew up a vegetarian and never developed this taste for meat that most people have. That’s great that you buy your meat from responsible producers- this alleviates many of the problems with American meat today (as far as health, treatment, etc.).

Ben LeVine

3. by anonymous on Oct 12, 2011 at 5:43 PM PDT

Well, it all depends on why you gave up meat in the first place, right? Or what that comes to mean to you over the course of your life? It sounds like your reasons for giving up meat had less to do with the food itself and more with self-identity and knowing who you were apart from your family. So when you have that identity established, it seems pretty simple to then go back to eating meat, no? Which is all fine - but it doesn’t really express why many people give up meat. In the end I guess it’s just really interesting how many ways food intersects with identity...

4. by anonymous on Oct 13, 2011 at 1:20 PM PDT

Regarding the first comment - I understand what you’re saying, of course it’s killing, but what’s that have to do with the article? That type of comment just demonizes meat-eating which in itself is not evil. We’re just at the top of the food chain (and back in the day...we certainly were not). I think the problem has more to do with the fact that food is presented to us all cut up and cleaned up with no indication of the process it undertook. I think if people were more involved in the process of raising and slaughtering like we used to be there would more respect for animals and how they are raised and likely less food waste too. Having said all this I’m not sure how to bring this about or how to convince others to reflect on their meat buying and eating habits (these days “cheap” seems to be a big buying factor; one I find completely distasteful especially when considering meat.)

I really like this article and think it was eloquently written. I enjoyed reading it.

5. by anonymous on Oct 14, 2011 at 10:26 AM PDT

Thank you for this article, very well spoken. I gave up meat for ethical reasons, then began raising animals myself in a natural and happy environment. . .the enjoyment and thankfulness of their life in order to give me life is eternal in my heart. I have truly revolved into a true omnivore and that is never forgotten whether at the table or in the pasture.

6. by anonymous on Nov 1, 2011 at 11:06 AM PDT

Great article. I’m incorporating vegetarian meals into my own cooking, but I’ll never quite eliminate meat, I think.

7. by anonymous on Nov 10, 2011 at 9:16 AM PST

I grew up eating meat 7 days a week and my mom was a wonderful cook. However, recently I started turning towards becoming a vegetarian and have eliminated meat (not necessarily seafood) from my diet. I have made this decision mainly based on the amount of hormones and additives that are added into meat. Last week I decided that I would have a gourmet hamburger from one of my favorite restaurants and to my suprise, it was not fantastic or great. It was just ordinary and was not what I expected. I left thinking “Yep, I would have rather had a vegetarian meal.”

8. by Rita Jacobs on Dec 3, 2012 at 4:36 AM PST

I love meat. My family loves meat. I can cook meat really well, (usually, the new grill is a tricky thing!!!) I stumbled upon this site because I ordered some vegetarian books and wanted to read reviews before they arrived. My family is full of picky eaters who consume a handful of veggies at best. I was totally afraid not to eat meat and shunned vegetarian anything. I too am facing a fear by diving in and learning. How do you create a balanced meal with no meat? How do you get your nutrition? Rather than say, “Impossible!”, I am ready to say, “How?”

Add a comment

Think before you type

Culinate welcomes comments that are on-topic, clean, and courteous. For the benefit of the community we reserve the right to delete comments that contain advertising, personal attacks, profanity, or which are thinly disguised attempts to promote another website.

Please enter your comment

Format: Bare URLs are automatically linked; use this style: [ "place text to be linked here"] for prettier links. You may specify *bold* or _italic_ text. No HTML please.

Please identify yourself

Not a member? Sign up!

Please prove that you’re not a computer

First Person

Contributions from farmers, cooks, and others who are tasting the many meanings of food.

Want more? Comb the archives.

Culinate 8

Kale in the raw

Eight versions of kale salad

Eight ways to spin everyone’s favorite salad.

Graze: Bites from the Site
First Person

The secret sharer

A father’s legacy

The Culinate Interview

Mollie Katzen

The vegetarian-cooking pioneer


Down South

Barbecue, tamales, cocktails, and more

Local Flavors

A winter romesco sauce

Good on everything

Editor’s Choice