Book Review

The less-meat diet

A review of ‘Food Matters’

By
April 17, 2009

You may know Mark Bittman best as the appealingly immodest guy behind the How to Cook Everything cookbook juggernaut (How to Cook Everything (Completely Revised 10th Anniversary Edition), How to Cook Everything Vegetarian, The Best Recipes in the World). Despite their heft, his cookbooks are terrifically approachable, with simple, easy-to-read recipes built around master plans. The whole goal? Empowering readers — even those who literally do not know how to boil water — to get into the kitchen and take charge of dinner.

Bittman is also the author of the long-running and popular New York Times food column "The Minimalist" and an associated blog, Bitten. He’s a frequent guest on the “Today” show and recently toured Iberia with the likes of Mario Batali and Gwyneth Paltrow for a PBS show on Spanish food. He’s a celebrity chef (albeit with no formal training) as well as something vaguer and more powerful: a food celebrity.

What you may not know about Bittman, though, is that he didn’t set out to become The Guy Who Reformed The American Kitchen. In fact, his first book — the little-known and plainly titled Fish — was nothing more than a straightforward (if thoroughly comprehensive) book about, well, cooking fish.

Fifteen years later, is Bittman going to update the book for a new audience? No. As he told the New York Observer late in 2008, Bittman “cannot update Fish because so many of the 70 species he wrote about have since disappeared.”

Instead, Bittman wrote a slender volume with the doublespeak title of Food Matters. Like the earlier and similar Grub, Food Matters is two books in one: half cookbook, half manifesto. Both halves are meant to make a whole sandwich: the chewy gristle of how our food system is destroying the planet slapped next to the crunchy green of guilt-free recipes.

Bittman’s goals in Food Matters are summed up on the book’s cover: “Lose Weight, Heal the Planet.” The losing-weight part is a classic dieting saga — in this case, Bittman’s own personal journey of slimming by cutting back on animal products and junk food and embracing more whole grains and produce. The healing-the-planet part is the book’s political angle — in this case, Bittman’s call to readers to follow his dietary example and thereby reduce the damage caused to the planet by our current system of intensive animal husbandry.

Critics have noted that Food Matters is essentially Michael Pollan Lite. Bittman doesn’t dispute this; he openly acknowledges his predecessors in the field of food politics, claiming only to offer a condensed version of their work for the CliffsNotes masses.

What Bittman doesn’t point out is that his central argument already had a round of media and popular attention a generation ago. As Gary Taubes notes in Good Calories, Bad Calories, Americans last got anxious about our diet’s drain on our planet and ourselves back in the late 1960s and early 1970s, with the publication of Paul Ehrlich’s 1968 bestseller The Population Bomb and Frances Moore Lappé’s 1971 bestseller Diet for a Small Planet. This “anti-meat movement,” as Taubes calls it, sparked a wave of vegetarianism and activism on behalf of using our planet’s resources in responsible agricultural ways — much like now.

Advertisement
How to Cook Everything ad

What’s the difference today? Back then, the argument was, “Eat less meat and no one will go hungry.” Share and share alike, in other words. Today, the argument is, “Eat less meat and stop global warming.” Free your steak, and planetary health will follow.

It’s hard to argue — then or now — with the claim that industrially raised meat is harmful to the animals involved, the environment, and the people who eat the (often drugged and diseased) animals. What’s less clear is that eating less meat is beneficial to our health. Admittedly, First Worlders generally indulge in meat-eating on a grand scale. But scientific studies of eating an all-meat diet have shown such diets to be perfectly healthy.

Bittman doesn’t make any explicit statements that his diet is the absolute healthiest way to eat, just that it works for him. But any book that stumps for a particular diet — what Bittman calls “lessmeatatarianism” or the “Vegan Until 6” diet — is implicitly advocating for a particular way of thinking about health.

Did Bittman lose weight (and become healthier, as he says) because he ate fewer animal products? Because he ate more greens and whole grains? Because he shunned refined flours and sugars? Or some combination thereof? It’s tricky to tell, and one man’s personal experience does not a scientifically controlled experiment make.

Plenty of people, obviously, choose to follow a flexitarian, vegetarian, or vegan diet for ethical instead of health reasons. But a diet designed to help the environment or animals isn’t necessarily a diet designed for humans — and it’s all too easy, as at least one blogger has noted, to consume a dreadful diet in the name of saving the planet.

veggies in colander
Mark Bittman wants you to eat more veggies.

That said, Bittman’s suggested diet is far from dreadful. Eating more greens and whole grains is indisputably healthy, as is eating fewer industrial animal products. (Bittman also attacks junk food and “overrefined carbohydrates” as an evil on a par with eating too many animal products. He tries to sum this up as “the industrial meat and junk food complex,” but this lengthy catchphrase gets buried beneath the book’s heavier emphasis on eating less meat.) What it all boils down to on the stovetop is nothing more complicated than this: Add veggies. Use whole grains instead of refined. Cut back on the animal products as you see fit. And that’s pretty much it.

The cookbook section of Food Matters — 75-odd recipes, along with pantry lists and eating plans — offers a quick primer in the Bittman way of thinking in the kitchen: Grasp basic techniques and recipes, then improvise. Readers used to Bittman’s heftier cookbooks, with their hundreds of recipes, may be disappointed here at the slim pickings — and indeed, it might make more sense to pick up a copy of How to Cook Everything Vegetarian and swap out refined products in that book for whole grains. (Bittman’s other cookbooks also tend to be better edited, avoiding such mistakes as calling couscous pasta a “whole grain” and claiming that chickens and pigs — omnivores both — are really herbivores.)

Another weakness of the book is its refusal to tell readers how to shop. Granted, as Bittman points out in How to Cook Everything Vegetarian, labels change frequently and many labels are meaningless, so telling readers to buy, say, only organic products can quickly sound dated. But if you’re doing what Bittman says he wants you to do — reducing your consumption of animal products instead of excising them from your diet completely — you might want tips on how to buy, say, milk that doesn’t come from industrially raised cows. Bittman’s failure to do so makes it hard to escape the conclusion that Food Matters, despite its claims to the contrary, is really a book about why and how to become a vegan.

Nevertheless, Food Matters remains a brilliantly condensed guide to the depredations of industrial food production. And despite its lack of convincing health science, there’s no reason not to adopt Bittman’s less-meat (and more greens and whole grains) diet. Do so, and you’ll likely save money; you’ll certainly feel virtuous. And maybe you’ll even get more creative in the kitchen, just as Bittman intended.

Caroline Cummins is Culinate’s managing editor.

Subscribe
Comments
There are 3 comments on this item
Add a comment
1. by TRISTA on Apr 17, 2009 at 4:59 PM PDT

It seems most experts agree that eating less meat and more veggies, fruits, and grains is good for your health and lighter on the planet. The main reason meat production is so harmful to the planet seems to be the horrible pollution of giant feed lots (concentrated animal feed operations, or CAFOs).

However, I know a few people who truly cannot imagine eating less meat, see the suggestion as political and not about health, and a few others who simply think they love meat too much to reduce it in their diet. Habits are hard to break, and when we love a food we really love a food. (It would take an army to get me to quit drinking coffee.)

So, one possible “happy medium” I haven’t read much about is alternative sources of animal protein, meaning, small, local, conscientiously managed ranches and farms--places where cows eat grass all the way to slaughter (not grain-finished) and their “cow pies” cool in the pastures where the ground soaks up much of the gasses contributing to global warming.

Is this a realistic option? How does one find (and afford?) meat that is produced by smaller sources impacting the planet less negatively? I don’t eat meat, so I’ve not researched it, but like farmed fish, mass-produced cows and pigs cause more problems to global warming than our driving. Not everyone can go veg or even reduce the amount of meat they eat, but maybe they can purchase meat more conscientiously?

2. by Syd on Apr 17, 2009 at 11:33 PM PDT

Wow, sounds like there’s, if not outright vegan hate then at least, vegan fear and disdain all through this review.

Makes one wonder... Why so defensive?

3. by Kathryn H on Apr 20, 2009 at 9:16 AM PDT

I just finished reading “Food Matters” and thought it was thought provoking and engaging. I do wish that Bittman had made a case for sourcing animal products from sustainable, local farmers. As Trista suggests factory farming of livestock has multiple environmental impacts that are reduced when animals are raised on pasture. Meat and dairy products from pastured cattle are healthier for humans to eat, if meat-eating is your choice. Trista, I would recommend that your friends seek out meat producers at farmers markets and ask how their animals are raised; another good source might be a food cooperative or natural foods store. As for the affordability of sustainable food, I think if one is concerned about personal and planetary health, then it may be time to think about re-prioritizing the monthly budget. The long-term benefits of eating locally and sustainably are priceless to me.

Add a comment

Think before you type

Culinate welcomes comments that are on-topic, clean, and courteous. For the benefit of the community we reserve the right to delete comments that contain advertising, personal attacks, profanity, or which are thinly disguised attempts to promote another website.

Please enter your comment

Format: Bare URLs are automatically linked; use this style: [http://www.example.com "place text to be linked here"] for prettier links. You may specify *bold* or _italic_ text. No HTML please.

Please identify yourself

Not a member? Sign up!

Please prove that you’re not a computer


Reviews

Culinate props open and ponders cookbooks, nonfiction, memoirs, and other books about food.

Want more? Comb the archives.

Advertisement
Our Table

The Joy of Cooking app

A new tool for the kitchen

The latest in our collection of cooking apps.

Subscribe
Graze: Bites from the Site
First Person

The secret sharer

A father’s legacy

The Culinate Interview

Mollie Katzen

The vegetarian-cooking pioneer

Reviews

Down South

Barbecue, tamales, cocktails, and more

Local Flavors

A winter romesco sauce

Good on everything

Editor’s Choice