Savita Iyer-Ahrestani is a journalist based in State College, Pennsylvania, who writes about business, parenting, travel, and food. She has lived in Switzerland, India, Malaysia, Myanmar, the United Kingdom, Holland, and New Jersey.

Homemade paneer

No need to buy frozen

November 12, 2012

There are two things I look for when I move to a new place: a beauty salon where they shape eyebrows with thread, and a store that sells Indian spices.

I was happy to be able to cross both items off my list a week after moving to the town that will be my home for the next two years. Here, I found an Iranian beautician adept in the art of eyebrow threading, and the local Wegmans is huge and well stocked, with spices from every corner of the world, including India.

There was still one thing missing, though: paneer, the milky Indian cheese I use frequently.

I assumed it would be a cinch to find, believing it would be in a freezer somewhere close to the Indian spices. But the chunks of frozen paneer that were in plentiful supply in the Indian grocery store near my former home were nowhere to be found here. And because paneer is a hot favorite in my household, I had soon exhausted the stock of slabs I’d brought before moving here.

With no paneer on hand, I had two choices: Forget about it altogether, or do something quite radical (for me, anyway) and learn how to make it myself.

When frozen paneer wasn’t available, she made her own.

Truth be told, there’s no way that frozen paneer can ever replace the soft perfection that is homemade paneer. But for whatever reason, I have always banked on the frozen kind, which really isn’t bad at all. As a busy working mother, I’m inclined toward taking the quick route wherever possible, so I had only half-listened to my mother when she repeatedly told me that homemade paneer is a piece of cake to make.

Suddenly, I felt the loneliness of being in a new place where I know no one; the distance from home washed over me in a huge wave of nostalgia for the Indian dishes of my childhood.

When I was growing up, Indian grocery stores didn’t exist, and there was no such thing as frozen paneer, so my mother always made it herself. At least twice a week, we ate her delicious Palak Paneer or Mutter Paneer (aka Mattar Paneer), the spinach and pea-based curries that are a staple in the cuisine of northern India and that my brother and I relished. A paneer dish is comfort food for me, and it has become that way for my children, too.

So, after some hesitation, I decided I would take on the challenge and make it myself. And there seemed no better occasion to do so than for Diwali, the Hindu festival of lights, which Hindus around the world will celebrate this Tuesday, November 13.

Our family isn’t planning any major celebration this year. We barely know anyone, as we’ve just moved here. We’re feeling bad for all our friends who suffered from the devastation that was Hurricane Sandy. We lost an uncle earlier in the year.

But for a Diwali-night dinner, a fragrant Mutter Paneer studded with chunks of paneer and laced with fresh coriander (cilantro) leaves will be perfection itself. It smacks of home, reminds us of those we love and miss, and brings us together as a family.

Just as my mother told me to, I purchased a half-gallon of whole milk and set half of it to boil in a saucepan. My mother, like all experienced cooks, has no measurements to impart. She tells me to simply drip lemon juice into the milk once it’s boiling and keep stirring it until it curdles. I am then to remove it quickly from the flames and strain it through a muslin cloth until it stops dripping. Then, I need to set it aside and place a heavy weight on top of it to let it set. It should be ready the next day to chop up into squares and put into my curry.


Mom was right on this one, too. Making my own paneer really was a piece of cake. Unfortunately, the batch I made for my trial run has already been consumed, and as I write this piece, I have not yet made my Diwali batch. But herein you have the simple steps to make your own paneer, and I’ll leave you with that.

The best Diwali wishes, from my family to yours.

Related recipe: Mom’s Mutter Paneer

There are 2 comments on this item
Add a comment
1. by Romeo on Nov 14, 2012 at 2:28 AM PST

I learned how to make paneer when reading the comments to an article talking about making ricotta cheese at home. Someone suggested in the comments essentially your method as a quick version, and was quickly corrected by other commenters as having made paneer (though, it does make a fine ricotta substitute if you’re not expecting to try and melt it!). It wasn’t until 3 or so years later that I got a taste of how it can be used by moving to Bahrain and eating a lot of Indian take out! It’s a really versatile ingredient. Thanks for the story!

2. by Jayden Bell on Dec 10, 2012 at 3:55 AM PST

In a bowl, combine any processed grated cheese, tomato ketchup, cumin powder, red chilli powder, pinch of salt, grated paneer, all-purpose flour, and bread crumbs. Mix all these ingredients together and knead to form dough. Gently squeeze out small popcorn size dumplings and keep aside or else roll the dough into thin cylindrical shape and cut into small piece (as shown in video). In a plate, mix equal quantities of corn flour, all-purpose flour and salt and mix well. Remove half the quantity of the flours in another plate. Add little water in one portion of the flour quantity and make a smooth paste free of lumps. Drop the small dumpling into the flour batter and coat them well. Remove and drop into the other portion of the dry flour and keep aside. Coat the entire dumplings in the same process. Heat oil in and pan and when the oil is hot, fry the coated dumplings on medium hot oil until they turn slight golden in colour and crisp. For the popcorn masala, in a bowl, add chaat masala, parmesan cheese (optional), marjoram and oregano, mix the spices together and sprinkle over the fried popcorn paneer.

Add a comment

Think before you type

Culinate welcomes comments that are on-topic, clean, and courteous. For the benefit of the community we reserve the right to delete comments that contain advertising, personal attacks, profanity, or which are thinly disguised attempts to promote another website.

Please enter your comment

Format: Bare URLs are automatically linked; use this style: [ "place text to be linked here"] for prettier links. You may specify *bold* or _italic_ text. No HTML please.

Please identify yourself

Not a member? Sign up!

Please prove that you’re not a computer

Culinate 8

Kale in the raw

Eight versions of kale salad

Eight ways to spin everyone’s favorite salad.

Graze: Bites from the Site
First Person

The secret sharer

A father’s legacy

The Culinate Interview

Mollie Katzen

The vegetarian-cooking pioneer


Down South

Barbecue, tamales, cocktails, and more

Local Flavors

A winter romesco sauce

Good on everything

Editor’s Choice